Fire Island, a true paradise for gay travelers, exudes an irresistible attraction with its cosmopolitan atmosphere and vibrant gay community. We have researched the 4 best gay hotels on Fire Island for you and taken a closer look under our LGBTQ magnifying glass.
This magical place not only offers miles of sandy beaches and vibrant parties, but also a warm invitation to be yourself.
In our search for the top 4 gay hotels in Fire Island, we focused specifically on those located in the island’s most popular gay hotspots. It was important to us that these hotels are either directly anchored in the gay community, are run by gay hosts or are particularly popular with the gay scene.
Our aim was to find a blend of unique local flair and first-class comfort to ensure that every visit is unforgettable. Fire Island is more than just a destination; it’s an experience that celebrates freedom and joy in a communal, celebrated environment.
We would be delighted if you would carry out your price comparison or hotel booking via one of our partner links. We receive a small commission when you book and can use it to pay the maintenance costs for this free blog. The price will not change for you, you will continue to receive the lowest prices! Thank you for your support! Find your hotel at Booking.com
4 stars from 250 $
Anyone checking into The Madison at Fire Island Pines will experience a real slice of gay heaven. The interior radiates with modern aesthetics and a touch of luxury, ideal for the modern LGBTQ+ traveler. The friendly staff also make you feel immediately welcome and understood. The atmosphere is lively yet relaxing – perfect for escaping the stresses of everyday life.
The rooms are a real eye-catcher: stylish, with comfortable beds and all the modern amenities you need for a carefree stay. A special highlight is the roof terrace, which offers a breathtaking view over the island and is a wonderful place to enjoy a drink in the evening.
Gay bars, clubs and cafés nearby:
Our rating:
2 stars from 150 $
Let’s immerse ourselves in the carefree atmosphere of Clegg’s Hotel, a charming gem in the heart of Fire Island that is particularly popular with the gay community. This hotel immediately captures every visitor with its rural, almost rustic charm. The focus here is on being together and enjoying yourself, perfect for all those who not only want to relax on vacation, but also make new contacts.
The rooms are simply furnished with attention to detail and offer a cozy retreat. What makes Clegg’s special is its open, inviting common room, which often serves as a meeting place for social evenings. A highlight is the roof terrace, from where you have a stunning view over the vibrant island – ideal for enjoying the sunset with a drink.
Gay bars, clubs and cafés nearby
Our rating:
3 stars from 200 $
A real gem for the gay community, The Palms Hotel Fire Island offers a charming escape with a special touch. With its trendy furnishings and warm, inviting ambience, it is a top address for anyone looking for something special. The rooms are stylishly furnished with a modern twist and offer every comfort you could wish for – perfect for your next Iceland getaway!
The proximity to the sea is of course a huge plus. Just imagine: You wake up in the morning and can already hear the sound of the waves. The pool area is also a real eye-catcher and ideal for meeting new people or simply relaxing. The staff are also particularly open-minded and helpful, especially when it comes to tips for the LGBT scene!
Gay bars, clubs and cafés nearby:
Our rating:
2 stars from 180 $
If you are looking for a real insider tip that skillfully combines style and budget, then the Grove Hotel is just your thing. This 2-star hotel not only offers a super central location, but also has that certain something that sets it apart from other budget hotels. The interior boasts clean lines and a trendy yet warm design that is immediately inviting. The rooms? Comfortable, modern and just the thing to relax in after an exciting day in the city.
But what makes the Grove Hotel really special? It’s the perfect mix of friendly service that never seems intrusive and a cool, urban atmosphere. Whether you are traveling alone or with friends, you will immediately feel welcome and at home here. It is also just a stone’s throw away from some of the city’s hottest gay hotspots.
Gay bars, clubs and cafés nearby
Our rating:
Thank you for taking the time to read our article about the top 4 gay hotels on Fire Island. We hope it was useful in planning your next gay vacation. Fire Island not only offers the vibrant gay district of Cherry Grove, but also a variety of gay resorts that are perfectly tailored to the needs of the LGBTQ+ community. Whether you are looking for relaxation or want to explore the nightlife, you are sure to find the right hotel here. Have fun during your stay and enjoy the unique atmosphere that this island has to offer!
Dansk (Danish)
Nederlands (Dutch)
English
Français (French)
Deutsch (German)
Italiano (Italian)
Polski (Polish)
Español (Spanish)
Svenska (Swedish)
Türkçe (Turkish)
Čeština (Czech)
Ελληνικά (Greek)
Português (Portuguese (Portugal))
Русский (Russian)
简体中文 (Chinese (Simplified))
Suomi (Finnish)
Magyar (Hungarian)
日本語 (Japanese)
한국어 (Korean)
Norsk bokmål (Norwegian Bokmål)
